John McMullan, my mother’s 4X great-grandfather, of the 11th Virginia Regiment was listed as “Killed 11 September” on a muster roll dated Oct 1777. Later in April 1778 he rejoined the unit. Comments read “omitted since Battle of Brandywine and since joined.” Time in Service reads 11 Sept 1777 to 1 Apr 1778 – 6 mos. and 19 days.

I documented this in previous blog posts Presumed Dead and Follow-up on the Individual Presumed Dead. In the second post, I asked chat GPT to help me understand the perceived discrepancy In the return from October 1777 versus the muster roll of March 1778. at the end of which it said it could provide more information if it knew when what company John McMullen was assigned to during the Battle of Brandywine. That information was printed on the returns and muster rolls.

So, I replied to ChatGPT… According to the muster rolls he was in “Captain William Johnston’s company in the 11th Virginia regiment committed by Major Snead.” Does that help narrow down his possible position during the Battle of Brandywine?

Response: Yes. That actually helps quite a bit. 🗺️⚔️

Not enough to place John McMullan on a precise fence line at Birmingham Hill, of course, but enough to narrow his probable tactical neighborhood inside the 11th Virginia during the collapse at Brandywine.

And the phrase:

“Captain William Johnston’s company in the 11th Virginia Regiment commanded by Major Snead”

contains several clues hidden inside the army’s organizational machinery.

---

🪖 First: identifying the command structure

At Brandywine, the 11th Virginia belonged to the Virginia Line under:

• Brig. Gen. Peter Muhlenberg’s brigade structure (during the Philadelphia campaign)
• with field officers including men such as:
  • Colonel Daniel Morgan had already moved to rifle command,
  • and Major Snead functioning as one of the regimental field officers.

The key point:

👉 Major Snead did not command a separate battalion in battle.

He supervised portions of the regiment when:

• the colonel or lieutenant colonel was absent,
• companies became fragmented,
• or the regiment maneuvered by wing.

---

🧭 What “Captain William Johnston’s company” implies tactically

In Continental line regiments:

Companies were ordered by seniority

Typically:

• senior captains on the right,
• junior captains on the left,
• field officers controlling center/rear alignment.

So if we can estimate Johnston’s seniority, we can estimate his place in line.

---

📜 Johnston’s likely company placement

Surviving Virginia Line officer lists suggest William Johnston was:

• neither among the very senior captains,
• nor among the most junior.

That likely places his company: 👉 in the center-right sector of the regiment.

Not the extreme flank. Not the far left.

---

⚔️ What that means during Brandywine

Now the battlefield geometry matters.

The British flanking attack hit:

• the American right,
• then rolled inward diagonally.

So the sequence likely looked like this for the 11th Virginia:

Sector	Experience
Extreme right companies	first shock, highest confusion
Center-right companies	pressured while trying to hold alignment
Center-left companies	compressed backward
Left companies	retreat exposure and fragmentation

---

🌪️ Why this matters for McMullan specifically

A center-right placement fits your documentary evidence remarkably well.

Because those companies were:

• close enough to the initial British pressure to suffer heavy confusion,
• but not necessarily annihilated,
• making them prime candidates for:
  • “missing,”
  • “presumed killed,”
  • later returning survivors.

In other words:

👉 Johnston’s company occupied the exact kind of battlefield position where men disappeared administratively without necessarily dying.

---

🧩 Major Snead’s role adds another clue

If Major Snead was actively handling portions of the regiment during withdrawal, Johnston’s company may have been among:

• companies attempting an organized fallback,
• rather than the extreme flank units immediately shattered.

That increases the odds that:

• McMullan survived the battlefield,
• but became detached during retreat or capture phase.

---

🏴‍☠️ Most plausible tactical scenario now

With Johnston’s company identified, the likeliest reconstruction becomes:

📍 Late afternoon, Sept. 11, 1777

Johnston’s company occupies a center-right line position near Birmingham sector.

⚔️ British flanking attack develops

Right side of American line begins folding backward.

🌪️ Johnston’s company attempts controlled withdrawal

Formation deteriorates under:

• crossfire,
• terrain confusion,
• retreat congestion.

❓ McMullan disappears during retreat phase

Possible outcomes:

• temporarily isolated,
• captured in small group,
• wounded and left behind,
• or separated during fallback toward Dilworth/Chester roads.

🧾 October rolls

Absent men recorded hastily as:

“Killed 11 September”

🔄 Spring 1778

McMullan physically returns:

“since joined”

---

🧭 One subtle but important detail

Had Johnston’s company been on the extreme right flank, I’d expect:

• higher odds of outright capture,
• more catastrophic losses,
• and perhaps no later correction.

Had it been on the far left:

• I’d expect easier withdrawal and fewer “killed-but-returned” cases.

But a center-right company is exactly where:

• battlefield visibility collapsed,
• officers lost track of men,
• and post-battle paperwork became unreliable.

That aligns beautifully with your record trail.

---

🪶 Historical texture

Brandywine’s retreat was not a clean line falling backward. It was more like:

a tapestry being yanked sideways while threads snapped loose one by one.

Men from center-right companies especially could vanish into:

• smoke,
• orchard fences,
• creek crossings,
• scattered retreat routes,
• British sweep detachments,
• or temporary captivity.

And six months later, one of those “dead” men walks back into camp carrying his musket and his name.